The art world seems happy to champion a few African American and African British voices, but it ignores the brutality of the African and working-class experience. This became blatantly obvious to me when I was looking at my gallery round up from this year, The ‘Music is Black’  at the V&A, ‘Project a Black Planet’ in the Barbican & The Tate’s ‘Hurvin Anderson Exhibition,’ – and  upon revisiting this article, the controversial current fourth plinth display ‘Lady in Blue’ – we seem to be in a very “Black British” moment.

There’s a cultural dichotomy here: the oppressed, the queer, the working class, and racialised culture are being avidly represented, but also in some ways ignored. It’s the white upper class who are most likely to consume and commodify this culture. Not necessarily out of love for the culture, but more for profit. That leaves the people who control the creative economy very far from the people who actually create it.

I recognised this in the gallery scene of the French film La Haine – a cult classic loved by people of all classes and colours – centered around three boys from completely different classes trying to blend into Paris’s upper class in a post-modernist environment. They don’t get it. Not because they lack ability, but because in their eyes the art is “ridiculous” – a mockery of “real art” made for the sake of moving money around. The film went on to win three César Awards and Best Director at Cannes, and it honestly has far more cultural impact than anything hanging in that room. The line that stays with me is “Le monde est à nous”, the world is ours. It echoes the question I keep coming back to: whose world is it?

Who are we making art for?

Who is actually coming to these galleries?

I can’t count the number of times I’ve been the only Black person in the room in these galleries, and that’s in this year alone. That isn’t to say people of colour are uncultured. Look at popular culture, fashion, music, even modernism: Black culture is essential to feeding the imaginations of so many Western artists.

Even in the UK, when most galleries are free to enter, it poses the question of time and education. This dichotomy is exactly why institutions that want to exhibit African art fully – not just as a month’s exhibition or a single portrait on a wall but art that is solely Black – can’t thrive. If Black art is only a trend to the people who exploit it, it can’t last.

Whenever anyone asks what my favourite exhibition was, I usually say the Noah Davis exhibition at the Barbican. I was already familiar with his widow, Karon Davis, from podcasts where she’d been a guest. Once I researched her further, I fell in love with her balletic sculptures of Black dancers. She did mention her late husband on those podcasts, but his work I never looked up. It was only when I found myself at the Barbican for my sister’s music camp that I saw the exhibition on a whim. It was the first time I cried in a gallery (and possibly in public). It was by the end, when admiring the final works he made towards the end of his life followed by a video of Davis himself, I couldn’t hold it back. Art means so much more than money and tax dodges. It’s life. Through the meticulous curation I’d relived the life of a man, so intimately that his death weighed heavy on my heart.

It was heartwrenching to see the Tiwani gallery go before I even got to experience it. Of course, with the economic collapse and the art world’s changing reception in recent years, a plethora of galleries across London are shutting down or  moving further east. But the hidden galleries in Hackney are still full of life and people, but rather those we might call “gentrifiers” rather than the audience the artist actually intended.

This issue of audience is more complex than we might recognise, though. At a careers event, Sonia E Barrett, the artist, said she only makes art for specific people. She doesn’t need to create for, or be understood by, communities that refuse to understand her personhood. Two things she said stuck with me:

“It’s a colonial idea to understand everything – the issue of criticism.”

“Trying to understand is an act of love.”

Do we try too hard to govern the artistic space and who visits? The gallery experience is so much more than the art you’re seeing; it can become a cultural study of the cycles of consumption.

Working at Frieze in October made me think about who modern art is really for. Around the same time, i-D published ‘Gallery Girls’ – an article that reduced women (rather high up in their art world careers) to girls. For me, this felt intentional, from the language of “gallery girls”, to positioning them as pawns for the upper-class consumers of art. They are “young”, needing  to be “educated” , and most of all, “below” those who have existed for longer within the industry. This is only a way to reduce the inevitable change the younger generation will and are beginning to have in the art world.

Working at this cultural event allowed me to realise that the people who work in the art world consist mostly from the upper class –  whose parents are already in the industry. This is why to land a job one needs: a string of unpaid internships, unaffordable degrees, cost to upkeep one’s appearance and travel fees.  This is what i-D reveal in their article, when, instead of highlighting the work these women are doing, emphasising what they’re wearing, who they know and where they visit.

The actual culture of change and revolution is suffocating under the weight of  the art world’s glossy image. We are left thinking that this world isn’t meant for us, when, in reality, it was made by us.


Edited by Gailie Tse

Cover image: Still from La Haine (Gallery Scene), 1985, Mathieu Kassovitz.

Leave a Reply

Trending